Sweet Potato Casserole & What Happens Under the Mistletoe

December 16th, 2015 Kimberly Feature, Review 61 Comments

16th Dec


Today I am sharing Sweet Potato Casserole & What Happens Under the Mistletoe . This scrumptious casserole dish is one that I serve for Thanksgiving and Christmas. It is to die for. It’s like dessert for dinner. Years and years ago when I worked in the corporate world we use to have pot lucks, and a gentleman from the IT department brought in this dish, and then was gracious enough to share the recipe. I will forever be thankful. Enjoy and be sure to check out my thoughts on What Happens Under the Mistletoe, this month’s book recommendation.



Pecan Sweet Potato Casserole



  • 3 cups of sweet potatoes skinned, cooked and mashed
  • 1/2 cup of sugar
  • 1/2 tsp. Salt
  • 2 eggs beaten
  • 1/2 stick of butter, melted
  • 1/2 cup milk
  • 1/2 tsp. vanilla


  • 1 cup brown sugar
  • 1/3 cup all-purpose flour
  • 1 cup chopped pecans (to desired  texture)
  • 1/2 stick of butter

  • Preheat oven to 350*
  • Lightly grease casserole dish/pie plate or 13 X 9 dish
  • Combine the potatoes, sugar, salt, eggs, butter, milk, and vanilla with a mixer.
  • Pour into greased dish
  • Combine toppings
  • Sprinkle toppings evenly over casserole
  • Bake at 350 for 35-40 minutes
  • Serves 4-8

Book Recommendation

Sweet Potato Casserole & What Happens Under the Mistletoe
What Happens Under the Mistletoe
by Sabrina Jeffries, Karen Hawkins, Candace Camp, Meredith Duran
Series: Sinful Suitors #1.5
Genres: Historical Romance
Source: Publisher
Purchase*: Amazon *affiliate
Rating: One StarOne StarOne StarHalf a Star
Heat Level: One FlameOne FlameOne Flame

New York Times bestselling authors Sabrina Jeffries, Karen Hawkins, and Candace Camp, and USA TODAY bestselling author Meredith Duran come together for a sizzling historical romance holiday anthology. Stunned by the heat of an unexpected kiss on a cold winter’s eve, two strangers from vastly different worlds turn hotheaded principles into burning passion in Sabrina Jeffries’s delightful yuletide story, "The Heiress and the Hothead". In the snowy Scottish countryside, Karen Hawkins’s rakish duke has an unforgettable holiday encounter in "Twelve Kisses" when the alluring lady he surprises under the mistletoe is not who he expected, but a long-lost love with a score to settle. In "By Any Other Name", Edinburgh is aglitter for Christmastime as Candace Camp sends a curious gentleman in hot pursuit of an intriguing lady in disguise—one who refuses to reveal her true identity, though she fears he has already stolen her heart with his kiss. In "Sweet Ruin", will the festive spirit of the season sweep Meredith Duran’s feisty heroine beneath the mistletoe—and back into the arms of the dashing rogue whose carelessness soiled her reputation and sent her into exile in London? In this all-new story collection sparkling with sexy charm and heartwarming wit, four beloved bestselling authors reveal the mix-ups and make-ups, the missed chances and golden opportunities that come but once a year.

historical Holiday WTF? coverlove

What Happens Under the Mistletoe is a delightful holiday anthology featuring short historical romances from Sabrina Jeffries, Karen Hawkins, Candace Camp and Meredith Duran. It contains four tales you can easily slip into during this busy holiday season. Each offers a delightful holiday romance so grab a cup of hot cocoa and snuggle up each night with one of these swoon-worthy romances.

The Heiress and the Hothead by Sabrina Jeffries-  A delightful tale in the Sinful Suitors series, that will work as a standalone. Amanda is from America and runs a mill at a Christmas party Lord Stephen attends in hopes of interviewing her. He spends his time writing about the deplorable conditions in London’ Cotton Mills, especially those that use children as young as five years of age. The romance was sweet, filled with banter and Mistletoe. I enjoyed the story until a certain sex scene had me declaring “what the fork?” The scene is very fade to black, but when and where the act took place..ridiculous. Aside from that the story was delightful.

Twelve Kisses by Karen Hawkins- A Scottish Duke kisses his mistress under the mistletoe only to discover it is someone from his past. This second chance romance has them trapped during a snowstorm where they are forced to work out their difference. The banter was entertaining as was the arguments and frustrations that they aired. Overall it was a sweet second chance romance to get you all warm and fuzzy.

By Any Other Name by Candace Camp- A woman dressed in disguise is searching for her missing brother.. Gregory attempts to help the young lad when he is in danger and imagine his surprise when he discovers she is woman. It was hilarious. Oh the wit!  Gregory is determined to learn her identity and the game is afoot. . Camp gives us some smooching, humor and romance. I laughed aloud more than once as the story unfolded.

Sweet Ruin by Meredith Duran- Georgiana and Lucas use to be in love then things fell apart and they parted angry and hurt. It is very obvious to outside observer that these two love each other and watching them bicker and nip at each other was pure entertainment. I loved the growth we saw in Georgiana and found I quite liked her. Twists and discovery kept things interesting on the way towards our HEA and this ended up being my favorite novella. It was delightfully written allowing me to feel the sexual tension and character’s emotions.

Photo of kimbacaffeinate
About Kimberly
Kimberly is a coffee loving book addict who reads and listens to fictional stories in all genres. Whovian, Ravenclaw, Howler and proud Nonna. She owns and manages Caffeinated PR. The coffee is always on and she is ready to chat. Twitter | Facebook | Instagram

61 Responses to “Sweet Potato Casserole & What Happens Under the Mistletoe”

  1. Ro

    That recipe sounds absolutely addictive and I’m trying it! BIG Hugs and Merry Christmas!

  2. Lorna

    So now you have me wanting to know where the sex scene takes place! This sounds like a great holiday anthology. Your casserole looks good but unfortunately sweet potatoes and I don’t mix. 🙂

  3. Cyn

    Yum! The sweet potato casserole looks delicious!
    Also, that was a really cute anthology, I just love Sabrina Jeffries! Lovely review!

  4. Adriana

    You’re singing my tune. I’ve become obsessed with sweet potatoes for a while now so this recipe is basically it for me.
    A long-lost love with a score to settle!? I’m loving all the anthology plot lines. Definitely, one to consider. Anthologies have surprised me before. They are better than I first suspected.

  5. Kristin

    OMG!! THAT’S what that icon means!!! I had no clue what the fork meant!!! And I really can’t imagine any sex scene being too weird for you! Seriously, a historical with weirdness? Really!?!?!?!

    And I think the Candace Camp one sounds like my absolute favorite trope!! Great reviews, recipe and I love your graphic!!! Your baker is HOT!!!

  6. Lark

    Your sweet potato recipe looks good – I may have to try it! I make one that has some butter, brown sugar, nutmeg, and a little bourbon in the potatoes, and then pecans or candied pecans on top. But I love sweet potatoes, so I’m always up for a new recipe! The book also looks good, but I think I’m anthologied out for a while! Maybe next year. 🙂

  7. Braine Talk Supe

    I’ve always be curious about SPC, saw a bunch of recipes and never tried any mainly because I don’t know how it’s supposed to taste. Like this is such a traditional dish, I don’t want to pick up some random recipe and consider it the benchmark.

    I have a wild hair on my butt this year though so I might give this a whirl beofre Christmas, practice and if I don’t bungle it up, I’ll make it for Christmas day.

    Thanks for sharing!

  8. Kathy

    That looks scrumptious! I love sweet potato casserole and have a similar recipe, but it uses walnuts in the topping. Sweet potato pie, sweet potato casserole, sweet potato donuts…I guess sweet potatoes are a staple here in the South. lol

  9. Melissa (Books and Things)

    I have to admit, I do like anthologies like that. I also love the sound of that casserole. So much better than the syrup/marshmallow disaster that you usually get. :p I would so eat the one you have here! Yum! Now, I’m hungry… 🙂

  10. Sophia Rose

    Oh yum! I have a similar recipe and haha, I got it from my co-worker, too. I haven’t made this in a while. My family would love it so thanks for sharing it.

    I didn’t grab this particular anthology because I had a pile already by the time I noticed it, but it sounds good. Lots of cuteness!

  11. Stormi

    I only really want that book for the Sabrina Jefferies story but I am sure the others are good too…lol. 🙂

  12. Heidi

    My brother found a recipe like this because he hates Yams at Christmas. I love it, the topping is the best part, we sometimes even make extra topping.

  13. Candace

    Oh that casserole sounds good and like something I can eat! I needed some sweet potato recipes so I’ll have to give this one a try!
    I don’t usually like novellas but I do enjoy the holiday ones. It’s a nice way to get into the holiday spirit.

  14. Quinn's Book Nook

    I really love holiday novellas. I don’t know what it is about them, but I can never resist them. I definitely need to look into this one, especially because I’ve never read any of these authors before. Even if not every story is AMAZING.

    • kimbacaffeinate

      I do too Quinn, I think its because we are so busy. It has taken me three nights to read a really good full length novel since I am running around with my head chopped off..but novellas I can start, enjoy and finish.

  15. Nick

    You know how I am with short stories, Kim. I would be drawn to all of these stories had they been full-length novels.
    That casserole looks amazing! I love all things casseroles. 🙂
    Lovely review!

  16. Angel Erin

    What a cool recipe. I’ve never had sweet potatoes with pecans. I have always had it with marshmallows. Which I know some people don’t like lol. 🙂

  17. Jenny

    I’m not a huge sweet potato person, but this sounds DELICIOUS! Anything in casserole format is a win to me:) And yay holiday historical romances! Exactly what I’m looking for at the moment Kim!

  18. Lekeisha

    I love all things sweet potato, so this looks like a great dish. It looks simple and I’ll have to make it separate because there are 4 people with tree nut allergies in my in-laws family. Thanks for sharing!

  19. Katherine

    Both the recipe and the book sound delicious! I love sweet potatoes but have never been a big fan of the kind with marshmallow toppings. I am a big fan of pecans so this sounds divine! I love Sabrina Jeffries and I haven’t read Karen Hawkins in ages. I definitely want to give the book a try!

  20. Tracy Terry

    A non-meat eater who is always on the look out for new things for Christmas dinner your sweet potato casserole sounds yummy.

  21. Red Iza

    Thanks for sharing the recipe, it’s mouthwatering 😀 I’ll soon be reading “The art of sinning” by Sabrina Jeffries, I hope there’ll be no fork involved 😉

  22. Ramona

    Sounds like a lovely anthology for the season. But, Kimba… The casserole! I was looking for a sweet potato recipe for Christmas – so I’ll be making this! Thank you so much <3

  23. melliane

    it’s an interesting recipe, I don’t think I’ve ever eaten potatoes with sweet… The book sounds nice once again; I miss reading HR now.