by Robin Oliveira
Series: Mary Sutter #2
Genres: Historical, Mystery
Source: Publisher
Purchase*: Amazon *affiliate
Rating:
From the New York Times bestselling author of My Name Is Mary Sutter comes a rich and compelling historical novel about the disappearance of two young girls after a cataclysmic blizzard, and what happens when their fate is discovered
New York, 1879: After an epic snow storm ravages the city of Albany, Dr. Mary Sutter, a former Civil War surgeon, begins a search for two little girls, the daughters of close friends killed by the storm who have vanished without a trace.
Mary's mother and niece Elizabeth, who has been studying violin in Paris, return to Albany upon learning of the girls' disappearance--but Elizabeth has another reason for wanting to come home, one she is not willing to reveal. Despite resistance from the community, who believe the girls to be dead, the family persists in their efforts to find the two sisters. When what happened to them is revealed, the uproar that ensues tears apart families, reputations, and even the social fabric of the city, exposing dark secrets about some of the most powerful of its citizens, and putting fragile loves and lives at great risk.
Please welcome Sophia Rose to Caffeinated as she takes us to Albany, New York in 1879 for a historical fiction wrapped in mystery. Come check out Winter Sisters by Robin Oliveira.
Sophia Rose’s Review
Albany, New York of 1879, an apocryphal unexpected blizzard, missing sisters, and an unspeakable act is set in motion.
Winter Sisters is the follow-up tale to My Name Is Mary Sutter. The events take place fourteen years after the end of the previous book. I had not read book one but did just fine starting with Winter Sisters. That said, this one would no doubt be spoiler-ish for My Name Is Mary Sutter as it recaps some of the past to set up for the events of Winter Sisters. I still plan to go back to Mary Sutter’s earlier story because I want to know and feel that one after this one.
So, Winter Sisters!
Wooboy, this was something. It is historical fiction and it is a mystery. It paints a vivid picture of the times and the people of Albany, New York. The author’s love for her hometown and her research shine through in this one. She brought this place to life, warts and all.
The story has an ominous tone as it slowly sets up for what is to come (be patient at the beginning). As a reader, my interest was given a gentle tug at first that grew and grew until I was gripped tight in this story. I don’t think I even breathed a few times near the end as I waited to see the culmination of all that had come before. It’s not heart-pounding danger and action, though there are moments of that, but just the build of a plot to its climax point that was deftly achieved.
The main plot centers around the disappearance of two young girls during a blizzard and then eventually what happened to them later during the spring thaw of the river and the subsequent flood. There are other plots circling around the central mystery. Mary’s ongoing fight for women’s health issues, Elizabeth’s private crisis over her musical talent, the Van Der Veer’s home situation, and more. They weave together quite well and the transitions were gentle between so I was not taken out of the story.
The mystery doesn’t happen in a vacuum. I loved how the historical setting and societal norms play a strong role. The author shows how things were thought about and handled back then from Mary’s reception by a misogynist police captain to the reaction of the city’s privileged, to the light shone on the lowly world of the prostitutes, to a woman’s lot in general from privileged wealth, and to children in that day. The real eyeopener for me was the take on medicine, mental health, and criminal law regarding the elements around the mystery. Let’s just say we have come far since then. Though, I know there are parallels of needed reform still in modern times. I’m deliberately being cagey about the plot because there are some real shockers and I don’t want to ruin it for potential readers.
The characters are vivid and colorful but are drawn with humanity in its strengths, weaknesses, good and terrible evil. The narrative shifts about from an unknown omniscient narrator to specific characters thoughts.
Mary is a central figure though she shares the limelight with others. I can’t address how far she has come since the earlier part of her story in book one, but I imagine existing fans will be delighted to encounter a middle-aged Mary and how she has stayed true to herself. She is a female doctor with high intelligence, drive, and unapologetic. She earns respect, but also fear wherever she goes. People, like the police chief, the head surgeon at the city hospital, and Gerrit Van der Veer bristle and try to dominate her when she inadvertently holds up a mirror where they see their weakness and inferiority in the face of her spirit, heroism, and drive. Mary is a voice for those who have no voice. She was an amazing character as were those who were close to her for loving her and wanting her just the way she was.
In some books, multiple narrators can feel dizzying and confusing, but for Winter Sisters, it really was a good choice. Getting the different points of view and how they saw the events didn’t diminish or distract but added so many layers. I think it made the story more visceral so I felt the punch of it, but it also gave me a break at times from the harsher and darker element. Elizabeth and Jakob’s courtship was sweet and I loved seeing Mary and William partnering in a more mature relationship.
All in all, I thought Winter Sisters was a fabulous and lush example of historical fiction and mystery blended well. I highly recommend it for those who enjoy strong female leads and American history of the late nineteenth century.
Winter Sisters by Robin Oliveira transports readers to 1879 Albany, New York and delivers a fictional historical mystery with strong female leads and rich look at the period. Share on X
Barbara Strickland
Like the idea of this
Sophia Rose
Thanks, Barbara! Hope you get the chance. 🙂
Lily
I have been on a huge HR kick lately. I have a physical copy of this and was looking for some time to read it, I’ll try to get to it sooner now that I read this lovely review.
Sophia Rose
Oh, yep! My reading mood works that way, too, Lily. Hope you end up liking it.
JoLee
That is awesome the author was able to have multiple narrators and did a good job. Do not see that a lot where is works out. Sometimes it is too much going on.
Sophia Rose
Yes, exactly! Usually, my head is reeling when I get more than two narrators, but this one delineated the breaks well and had such individual voices even while adding nice nuances like all parts of a whole so it was well done.
Nadene
Like Vanessa, I am not keen on the historical genre, but this sounds intriguing.
Sophia Rose
I think this one is a good one for folks who don’t particularly gravitate toward HF, but want to try it now and then b/c it comes with the great mystery element.
Stormi Johnson
I didn’t read much but since you enjoyed it I went and put the first one on hold on overdrive as I try my best to go in order. 🙂
Sophia Rose
My library has book one, too. I’m definitely going back for it. I think book one is not a mystery, but it does sound good since its set during the Civil War.
Debbie Haupt
Oh this sounds really good Sophia Rose I like historical fiction.
Sophia Rose
It was scrumptious, Debbie. I definitely want to go back for the first book though I’m not sure its a mystery, but it is Civil War. 😉
Katherine @ I Wish I Lived in a Library
I’ve been loving historical mysteries lately and this sounds fascinating! I’m glad to hear that I can jump in straight with this book. Adding it to my TBR!
Sophia Rose
I’ve been in the mood for some time and grabbed up a stack of them. This was a first time author and series for me and it worked out well, Katherine!
Kari @ Kari Reads and Writes
A great historical mystery, ooh, I’m in! I really want to read this one now, even though I didn’t read Mary Sutter first. I do like this genre but don’t always find titles that appeal to me. Thanks Sophia Rose, for your review!
Sophia Rose
Glad to pique your interest, Kari! 🙂
Ann Marie
Love HF combined with mystery/suspense. This one sounds fantastic. Great review!
Sophia Rose
You’re in for a treat when you get the chance to give this one a go, Ann Marie!
Lorna
This one sounds so intriguing. You have my mind wondering all sorts of things about the little girls. And the horrible storm. I like that it’s a historical mystery. I’ve been watching The Alienist on tv and it’s a historical mystery with children as victims. It’s excellent. Anyway, great review!
Sophia Rose
Oh yes, I’ve caught some of the Alienist and thought it was great that they did a TV series for a historical mystery.
This one would actually make a good TV adaption, I think.
Laura Thomas
Wonderful review. Historical mysteries aren’t something I read that often, which is odd since I love watching movies in the genre. This sounds like one I’d find hard to put down.
Sophia Rose
Thanks, Laura!
I love watching historical mysteries and historical drama, too. 🙂
Melissa (Books and Things)
This sounds so good and I love how the background with the mystery blended well. I’m also curious because of the multiple narrators. Sometimes that works very well.
Sophia Rose
Yes, the multiple narrators doesn’t always work for me, but in this case, it was like getting extra perspective on a situation rather than a distraction especially during the upheaval of discovery.
AngelErin
I don’t think I’ve heard of this one at all, but it does sound good! I like historical novels from time to time.
Sophia Rose
Yes! This one is a nice change up when you’re looking for something different from the contemporary stuff.
Angela Adams
I don’t have too many historical novels on my TBR list, but I am definitely adding this one! Thanks for the post.
Sophia Rose
Glad to hook you in, Angela. 🙂
Mary
This sounds really good. I loved your review! I love a good mystery and for it to be historical is even better!
Sophia Rose
Oh yes, mystery with history is like the sundae with the cherry on top, Mary. 🙂
Tyler H. Jolley
Great review, Sophia Rose. I hope all is well.
Sophia Rose
Thanks, Tyler!
Oh yes, doing great and wishing you the same.
Mary Kirkland
Oh this sounds good. Thanks for the great review.
Sophia Rose
Sure thing, Mary!
I was thrilled when it was offered to me since I was already curious about the author’s earlier book.
Silvia
Historical fiction and mystery can be a powerful and very interesting mix, so you can see why this one sounds good to me! Thanks for reviewing and putting a new title under my nose 🙂
Sophia Rose
I’m a big sucker for this combo, too. Glad to introduce you, Silvia. 🙂
Vanessa
I’m honestly not yet comfortable with historical genre but if it’s with suspense and mystery, I’m in!
Sophia Rose
I can see not wanting all the history especially if its for somewhere else. But yes, this one has some great suspense and mystery with it. 🙂
Melliane
I like the historical fiction/mystery mix so I’m intrigued by this one as well!
Sophia Rose
That combination is one of my favorites and I am always on the hunt for more. 🙂